All-Americans
Football All-Americans (Five players, seven awards)
| Name | Class | Award, Organization | Year |
| Howard Vandersea | 1963 | AP Little All-America, Third Team | 1962 |
| Paul Williamson’s Little All-America | 1962 | ||
| Larry DiGiammarino | 1982 | Kodak-American Football Coaches Association College Division III | 1981 |
| Chris Hickey | 1988 | Honorable Mention, AP Little All-America | 1986 |
| Honorable Mention, AP Little All-America | 1987 | ||
| Ron Gabbe | 1988 | Honorable Mention, AP Little All-America | 1987 |
| Jason Coulie | 2000 | Honorable Mention, USAFootball.com | 1999 |